Harry and Meghan Stayed Silent. Here’s Why Founders Pay a ‘Silence Tax’ When They Wait to Explain a Major Decision

Keeping silent might seem like playing it safe, but information vacuums suck in storytellers who want to get indexed on Google.

Meghan, Duchess of Sussex and Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex. Photo:

Prince Harry and Meghan surprised everyone by suddenly moving from California to the Cotswolds without so much as a comment. The internet had questions, so “undisclosed sources,” including palace-adjacent psychics, people close to the couple (by binoculars), and some guy with a Netflix subscription, quickly provided answers. They’re trying to save (or dissolve) their marriage. They’re running from failure. They want to be near the ailing King (or want to annoy future royals). And my favorite—their kids have been on a school waitlist since birth and finally got an acceptance letter, so they hopped on a plane.

Keeping silent might seem like playing it safe, but information vacuums suck in storytellers who want to get indexed on Google. And scandal sells, so the stories are more likely to be like Mean Girls and Succession than The Brady Bunch and Ted Lasso.

• Every decision you make will be analyzed through two lenses: “What are they gaining?” and “How are they lying, cheating, or hurting others?”
• Announce layoffs without a reasonable rationale, and YouTubers will do exposés on why your company is dying.
• Raise prices or remove a feature without context, and Redditors will call you a “greedy startup screwing customers.”
• Announce a key departure with, “We wish him all the best,” and people will assume that someone found some bodies.
• Ask employees to return to the office for no good reason, and they’ll post, “They want us to quit so they don’t have to pay severance.”
• Change your privacy policy in small print, and people will say you’re selling customers to the highest bidder or the surveillance state.
• Stop sharing updates, and everyone will assume you’re too scared to show the numbers.
• Introduce AI chat support without showing how it’s a genuine improvement, and headlines will say you’ve “replaced people who didn’t care with robots who can’t.”
• If you don’t seize the story in the first 24 hours after a major event, change, or announcement, you’ll pay a “silence tax” that compounds daily. By the time you realize that search results are serving up more exposés than accolades about you, it’ll cost ten times more to fix than it would have to prevent.

Here’s how to control the narrative:

1. Make a holding statement within 24 hours

Tell people what you’re doing, why you’re doing it, and when you’ll share more. Don’t write a novel or manifesto. Just state a few facts that prevent the worst speculation from dominating search results.

2. Don’t try to ‘have it both ways’

or avoid elephants in rooms with vague ambiguities. People hate hypocrisy and hiding. If your statement could be interpreted as “I’m doing it, but I’m not,” or “I’m guilty but I’m innocent” by a cynical observer, rewrite it until your stance is clear and direct. You can’t control all the narratives, so pick the one that matters the most. Decide who you really need to address and speak directly to their concerns.

The daily digest for entrepreneurs and business leaders

An Inc.com Featured Presentation

3. Know when to keep quiet and when to speak

Silence is fine if nobody expects you to say anything, but if all eyes are on you and inquiring minds “want to know,” keeping quiet will become a nefarious part of the story. Staying silent works on small controversies unrelated to your core values, but it backfires big time if the issue directly impacts stakeholder trust or makes headlines.

4. Don’t over-explain 

Saying too much is just as bad (or worse) than saying nothing. Don’t put out a post that says, “I want to be honest about this situation. The board pushed us to chase growth, our former VP of Product didn’t understand the vision, our biggest customer wanted an unrealistic feature, and I’ve barely slept in three months… We’ve made mistakes, but the people criticizing us don’t understand what it takes to build...”  Tell stakeholders what they need to know; don’t give them juicy tidbits that can be interpreted, amplified, and used against you.

5. Demonstration beats declaration

Long-term narrative control comes from taking consistent visible action. Uber didn’t turn around its 2017 crisis with apologies and a press release, but with leadership changes tied to important metrics, quarterly safety reports, and visible product improvements. They rebuilt trust over 18 months, not 8 days. After any headline-grabbing incident, plan three to five visible, values-aligned actions you can take and talk about for the next six months.

Waiting too long to say anything, blaming external factors, saying “no comment,” deleting negative comments, and using slippery language that sounds like it was written by a lawyer, are all big no-nos when you want to control a narrative.

Source: www.inc.com